Click to Login

Example: Credit card debt (2-quarters ahead)

NY Fed HHDC credit-card balances, univariate ARIMA two-quarter-ahead

This model estimates Credit card debt two quarters ahead (six months) with a univariate ARIMA on the New York Fed Household Debt and Credit series. The New York Fed series is quarterly; the six-month horizon is two HHDC quarters. Macro FRED prints are not used.

Our ARIMA model is

CCDEBT_estimated(t) = ARIMA(2,0,1)(0,1,1)[4] two-quarter-ahead from y through t−2q

and yields R^2 = 92.7% as of October 2023 (n = 71 quarters) in-sample on paired actuals through 2023Q4.
On later paired actuals the same frozen coefficients yield R^2 = 88.6% as of April 2026 (n = 10 quarters) out of sample.

The model is a univariate ARIMA fit on the target series from 2004 through 2023Q4. Each print is a two-quarter-ahead forecast from y through t minus that horizon, using those frozen coefficients. On the leftover paired actuals that frozen fit beats predicting the holdout mean. The first R² above is in-sample through 2023Q4 on the same two-quarter-ahead rule; the second is out-of-sample on later paired actuals.

Tabular Data

Date CCDEBT(t−2q) CCDEBT_actual(t) CCDEBT_estimated(t) CCDEBT_estimated(t) − CCDEBT_actual(t)
2026-10-01
(2026Q4)
1.263 1.3028
2026-07-01
(2026Q3)
1.242 1.2566
2026-04-01
(2026Q2)
1.277 1.263 1.2558 -0.0072 (-0.6%)
2026-01-01
(2026Q1)
1.233 1.242 1.2304 -0.0116 (-0.9%)
2025-10-01
(2025Q4)
1.209 1.277 1.255 -0.022 (-1.7%)
2025-07-01
(2025Q3)
1.182 1.233 1.1979 -0.0351 (-2.8%)
2025-04-01
(2025Q2)
1.211 1.209 1.1935 -0.0155 (-1.3%)
2025-01-01
(2025Q1)
1.166 1.182 1.1686 -0.0134 (-1.1%)
2024-10-01
(2024Q4)
1.142 1.211 1.1976 -0.0134 (-1.1%)
2024-07-01
(2024Q3)
1.115 1.166 1.1523 -0.0137 (-1.2%)
2024-04-01
(2024Q2)
1.129 1.142 1.1318 -0.0102 (-0.9%)
2024-01-01
(2024Q1)
1.079 1.115 1.121 0.006 (0.5%)
2023-10-01
(2023Q4)
1.031 1.129 1.1143 -0.0147 (-1.3%)
2023-07-01
(2023Q3)
0.986 1.079 1.0379 -0.0411 (-3.8%)
2023-04-01
(2023Q2)
0.986 1.031 0.9983 -0.0327 (-3.2%)
2023-01-01
(2023Q1)
0.925 0.986 0.964 -0.022 (-2.2%)
2022-10-01
(2022Q4)
0.887 0.986 0.9735 -0.0125 (-1.3%)
2022-07-01
(2022Q3)
0.841 0.925 0.8692 -0.0558 (-6.0%)
2022-04-01
(2022Q2)
0.856 0.887 0.8482 -0.0388 (-4.4%)
2022-01-01
(2022Q1)
0.804 0.841 0.8105 -0.0305 (-3.6%)
2021-10-01
(2021Q4)
0.787 0.856 0.8316 -0.0244 (-2.9%)
2021-07-01
(2021Q3)
0.77 0.804 0.7339 -0.0701 (-8.7%)
2021-04-01
(2021Q2)
0.819 0.787 0.7496 -0.0374 (-4.8%)
2021-01-01
(2021Q1)
0.807 0.77 0.7604 -0.0096 (-1.2%)
2020-10-01
(2020Q4)
0.817 0.819 0.776 -0.043 (-5.3%)
2020-07-01
(2020Q3)
0.893 0.807 0.9067 0.0997 (12.4%)
2020-04-01
(2020Q2)
0.927 0.817 0.9309 0.1139 (13.9%)
2020-01-01
(2020Q1)
0.881 0.893 0.874 -0.019 (-2.1%)
2019-10-01
(2019Q4)
0.868 0.927 0.8997 -0.0273 (-2.9%)
2019-07-01
(2019Q3)
0.848 0.881 0.8653 -0.0157 (-1.8%)
2019-04-01
(2019Q2)
0.87 0.868 0.8595 -0.0085 (-1.0%)
2019-01-01
(2019Q1)
0.844 0.848 0.8379 -0.0101 (-1.2%)
2018-10-01
(2018Q4)
0.829 0.87 0.8568 -0.0132 (-1.5%)
2018-07-01
(2018Q3)
0.815 0.844 0.8378 -0.0062 (-0.7%)
2018-04-01
(2018Q2)
0.834 0.829 0.8318 0.0028 (0.3%)
2018-01-01
(2018Q1)
0.808 0.815 0.8164 0.0014 (0.2%)
2017-10-01
(2017Q4)
0.784 0.834 0.8184 -0.0156 (-1.9%)
2017-07-01
(2017Q3)
0.764 0.808 0.7912 -0.0168 (-2.1%)
2017-04-01
(2017Q2)
0.779 0.784 0.7848 0.0008 (0.1%)
2017-01-01
(2017Q1)
0.747 0.764 0.7492 -0.0148 (-1.9%)
2016-10-01
(2016Q4)
0.729 0.779 0.7552 -0.0238 (-3.1%)
2016-07-01
(2016Q3)
0.712 0.747 0.7284 -0.0186 (-2.5%)
2016-04-01
(2016Q2)
0.733 0.729 0.7304 0.0014 (0.2%)
2016-01-01
(2016Q1)
0.714 0.712 0.7156 0.0036 (0.5%)
2015-10-01
(2015Q4)
0.703 0.733 0.7358 0.0028 (0.4%)
2015-07-01
(2015Q3)
0.684 0.714 0.7043 -0.0097 (-1.4%)
2015-04-01
(2015Q2)
0.7 0.703 0.6984 -0.0046 (-0.7%)
2015-01-01
(2015Q1)
0.68 0.684 0.6788 -0.0052 (-0.8%)
2014-10-01
(2014Q4)
0.669 0.7 0.6902 -0.0098 (-1.4%)
2014-07-01
(2014Q3)
0.659 0.68 0.6669 -0.0131 (-1.9%)
2014-04-01
(2014Q2)
0.683 0.669 0.6743 0.0053 (0.8%)
2014-01-01
(2014Q1)
0.672 0.659 0.6675 0.0085 (1.3%)
2013-10-01
(2013Q4)
0.668 0.683 0.6902 0.0072 (1.1%)
2013-07-01
(2013Q3)
0.66 0.672 0.6679 -0.0041 (-0.6%)
2013-04-01
(2013Q2)
0.679 0.668 0.6604 -0.0076 (-1.1%)
2013-01-01
(2013Q1)
0.674 0.66 0.663 0.003 (0.5%)
2012-10-01
(2012Q4)
0.672 0.679 0.6795 0.0005 (0.1%)
2012-07-01
(2012Q3)
0.6788 0.674 0.6839 0.0099 (1.5%)
2012-04-01
(2012Q2)
0.704 0.672 0.6932 0.0212 (3.2%)
2012-01-01
(2012Q1)
0.6933 0.6788 0.6768 -0.002 (-0.3%)
2011-10-01
(2011Q4)
0.6943 0.704 0.6964 -0.0076 (-1.1%)
2011-07-01
(2011Q3)
0.6964 0.6933 0.6833 -0.01 (-1.4%)
2011-04-01
(2011Q2)
0.7296 0.6943 0.7015 0.0072 (1.0%)
2011-01-01
(2011Q1)
0.7311 0.6964 0.6934 -0.003 (-0.4%)
2010-10-01
(2010Q4)
0.7444 0.7296 0.7245 -0.0051 (-0.7%)
2010-07-01
(2010Q3)
0.7624 0.7311 0.7422 0.0111 (1.5%)
2010-04-01
(2010Q2)
0.795 0.7444 0.7501 0.0057 (0.8%)
2010-01-01
(2010Q1)
0.812 0.7624 0.7736 0.0112 (1.5%)
2009-10-01
(2009Q4)
0.824 0.795 0.8071 0.0121 (1.5%)
2009-07-01
(2009Q3)
0.843 0.812 0.8469 0.0349 (4.3%)
2009-04-01
(2009Q2)
0.866 0.824 0.8588 0.0348 (4.2%)
2009-01-01
(2009Q1)
0.858 0.843 0.8483 0.0053 (0.6%)
2008-10-01
(2008Q4)
0.85 0.866 0.8691 0.0031 (0.4%)
2008-07-01
(2008Q3)
0.837 0.858 0.8712 0.0132 (1.5%)
2008-04-01
(2008Q2)
0.839 0.85 0.8544 0.0044 (0.5%)
2008-01-01
(2008Q1)
0.817 0.837 0.8237 -0.0133 (-1.6%)
2007-10-01
(2007Q4)
0.796 0.839 0.833 -0.006 (-0.7%)
2007-07-01
(2007Q3)
0.764 0.817 0.7904 -0.0266 (-3.3%)
2007-04-01
(2007Q2)
0.767 0.796 0.7675 -0.0285 (-3.6%)
2007-01-01
(2007Q1)
0.754 0.764 0.7506 -0.0134 (-1.8%)
2006-10-01
(2006Q4)
0.739 0.767 0.762 -0.005 (-0.7%)
2006-07-01
(2006Q3)
0.723 0.754 0.7331 -0.0209 (-2.8%)
2006-04-01
(2006Q2)
0.736 0.739 0.7272 -0.0118 (-1.6%)
2006-01-01
(2006Q1)
0.723
2005-10-01
(2005Q4)
0.736
2005-07-01
(2005Q3)
0.732
2005-04-01
(2005Q2)
0.717
2005-01-01
(2005Q1)
0.71
2004-10-01
(2004Q4)
0.717
2004-07-01
(2004Q3)
0.706
2004-04-01
(2004Q2)
0.697
2004-01-01
(2004Q1)
0.695