Click to Login

Example: C&I SLOOS tightening (2-quarters ahead)

SLOOS C&I tightening from unemployment and the Chicago Fed NFCI

This model estimates the SLOOS net percentage of banks tightening C&I standards for large and middle-market firms two quarters ahead from the civilian unemployment rate and the Chicago Fed National Financial Conditions Index, both dated six months earlier. Coefficients are ordinary least squares on the first 60% of complete lagged pairs from 2004 and then frozen.

  • UNRATE: civilian unemployment rate for the month six months before the quarter being forecasted
  • NFCI: Chicago Fed National Financial Conditions Index for that same month

Our regression model is

SLOOS_estimated(t) = UNRATE * -5.265541038 + NFCI * 23.144768995 + 41.530059139

and yields R^2 = 55.4% as of April 2017 (n = 54 quarters) in-sample on paired actuals through 2017Q2.
On later paired actuals the same frozen coefficients yield R^2 = 6.4% as of April 2026 (n = 37 quarters) out of sample.

Coefficients are ordinary least squares on the first 60% of complete lagged pairs from 2004 (through 2017Q2). The remaining 40% of paired actuals, including the period shown as a forecast, use those frozen coefficients. On that leftover window the frozen fit beats predicting the holdout mean. The first R² above is in-sample through 2017Q2; the second is out-of-sample on later paired actuals.

Tabular Data

Date UNRATE(t−6) NFCI(t−6) SLOOS_actual(t) SLOOS_estimated(t) SLOOS_estimated(t) − SLOOS_actual(t)
2027-01-01
(2027Q1)
4.1 -0.531 7.6515
2026-10-01
(2026Q4)
4.3 -0.481 7.7556
2026-07-01
(2026Q3)
4.3 -0.564 5.8346
2026-04-01
(2026Q2)
4.45 -0.52 8.1 6.0631 -2.0369 (-25.1%)
2026-01-01
(2026Q1)
4.3 -0.511 5.3 7.0613 1.7613 (33.2%)
2025-10-01
(2025Q4)
4.2 -0.386 6.5 10.4809 3.9809 (61.2%)
2025-07-01
(2025Q3)
4.0 -0.499 9.5 8.9187 -0.5813 (-6.1%)
2025-04-01
(2025Q2)
4.1 -0.438 18.5 9.8039 -8.6961 (-47.0%)
2025-01-01
(2025Q1)
4.2 -0.365 6.2 10.9669 4.7669 (76.9%)
2024-10-01
(2024Q4)
3.9 -0.419 0.0 11.2968 11.2968
2024-07-01
(2024Q3)
3.7 -0.385 7.9 13.1368 5.2368 (66.3%)
2024-04-01
(2024Q2)
3.9 -0.288 15.6 14.3288 -1.2712 (-8.1%)
2024-01-01
(2024Q1)
3.5 -0.256 14.5 17.1756 2.6756 (18.5%)
2023-10-01
(2023Q4)
3.4 -0.167 33.9 19.762 -14.138 (-41.7%)
2023-07-01
(2023Q3)
3.5 -0.274 50.8 16.759 -34.041 (-67.0%)
2023-04-01
(2023Q2)
3.6 -0.099 46.0 20.2828 -25.7172 (-55.9%)
2023-01-01
(2023Q1)
3.5 -0.179 44.8 18.9578 -25.8422 (-57.7%)
2022-10-01
(2022Q4)
3.7 -0.353 39.1 13.8775 -25.2225 (-64.5%)
2022-07-01
(2022Q3)
4.0 -0.557 24.2 7.5763 -16.6237 (-68.7%)
2022-04-01
(2022Q2)
4.5 -0.646 -1.5 2.8836 4.3836 (-292.2%)
2022-01-01
(2022Q1)
5.4 -0.672 -14.5 -2.4571 12.0429 (-83.1%)
2021-10-01
(2021Q4)
6.1 -0.673 -18.2 -6.1662 12.0338 (-66.1%)
2021-07-01
(2021Q3)
6.4 -0.62 -32.4 -6.5192 25.8808 (-79.9%)
2021-04-01
(2021Q2)
6.9 -0.498 -15.1 -6.3283 8.7717 (-58.1%)
2021-01-01
(2021Q1)
10.2 -0.44 5.5 -22.3622 -27.8622 (-506.6%)
2020-10-01
(2020Q4)
14.8 0.255 37.7 -30.498 -68.198 (-180.9%)
2020-07-01
(2020Q3)
3.6 -0.608 71.2 8.5021 -62.6979 (-88.1%)
2020-04-01
(2020Q2)
3.6 -0.534 41.5 10.2148 -31.2852 (-75.4%)
2020-01-01
(2020Q1)
3.7 -0.583 0.0 8.5542 8.5542
2019-10-01
(2019Q4)
3.7 -0.617 5.4 7.7672 2.3672 (43.8%)
2019-07-01
(2019Q3)
4.0 -0.479 -2.8 9.3816 12.1816 (-435.1%)
2019-04-01
(2019Q2)
3.8 -0.573 -4.2 8.2591 12.4591 (-296.6%)
2019-01-01
(2019Q1)
3.8 -0.554 2.8 8.6988 5.8988 (210.7%)
2018-10-01
(2018Q4)
4.0 -0.519 -15.9 8.4558 24.3558 (-153.2%)
2018-07-01
(2018Q3)
4.0 -0.614 -15.9 6.257 22.157 (-139.4%)
2018-04-01
(2018Q2)
4.2 -0.588 -11.3 5.8057 17.1057 (-151.4%)
2018-01-01
(2018Q1)
4.3 -0.576 -10.0 5.5568 15.5568 (-155.6%)
2017-10-01
(2017Q4)
4.4 -0.5 -8.5 6.7893 15.2893 (-179.9%)
2017-07-01
(2017Q3)
4.7 -0.485 -3.9 5.5568 9.4568 (-242.5%)
2017-04-01
(2017Q2)
4.9 -0.369 -2.8 7.1885 9.9885 (-356.7%)
2017-01-01
(2017Q1)
4.8 -0.359 1.4 7.9465 6.5465 (467.6%)
2016-10-01
(2016Q4)
5.1 -0.39 1.5 5.6493 4.1493 (276.6%)
2016-07-01
(2016Q3)
4.8 -0.321 8.5 8.826 0.326 (3.8%)
2016-04-01
(2016Q2)
5.0 -0.447 11.6 4.8566 -6.7434 (-58.1%)
2016-01-01
(2016Q1)
5.2 -0.526 8.2 1.9751 -6.2249 (-75.9%)
2015-10-01
(2015Q4)
5.4 -0.55 7.4 0.3665 -7.0335 (-95.0%)
2015-07-01
(2015Q3)
5.7 -0.531 -7.0 -0.7734 6.2266 (-89.0%)
2015-04-01
(2015Q2)
5.7 -0.655 -5.3 -3.6433 1.6567 (-31.3%)
2015-01-01
(2015Q1)
6.2 -0.769 -5.5 -8.9146 -3.4146 (62.1%)
2014-10-01
(2014Q4)
6.2 -0.786 -10.5 -9.3081 1.1919 (-11.4%)
2014-07-01
(2014Q3)
6.6 -0.787 -10.7 -11.4374 -0.7374 (6.9%)
2014-04-01
(2014Q2)
7.2 -0.728 -11.1 -13.2312 -2.1312 (19.2%)
2014-01-01
(2014Q1)
7.3 -0.67 -13.7 -12.4154 1.2846 (-9.4%)
2013-10-01
(2013Q4)
7.6 -0.716 -8.3 -15.0597 -6.7597 (81.4%)
2013-07-01
(2013Q3)
8.0 -0.655 -18.1 -15.7541 2.3459 (-13.0%)
2013-04-01
(2013Q2)
7.8 -0.581 -19.1 -12.9883 6.1117 (-32.0%)
2013-01-01
(2013Q1)
8.2 -0.38 -7.4 -10.4424 -3.0424 (41.1%)
2012-10-01
(2012Q4)
8.2 -0.453 -7.6 -12.132 -4.532 (59.6%)
2012-07-01
(2012Q3)
8.3 -0.309 -9.5 -9.3257 0.1743 (-1.8%)
2012-04-01
(2012Q2)
8.8 -0.133 -6.9 -7.885 -0.985 (14.3%)
2012-01-01
(2012Q1)
9.0 -0.496 5.4 -17.3396 -22.7396 (-421.1%)
2011-10-01
(2011Q4)
9.1 -0.608 -5.9 -20.4584 -14.5584 (246.8%)
2011-07-01
(2011Q3)
9.1 -0.6 -21.8 -20.2732 1.5268 (-7.0%)
2011-04-01
(2011Q2)
9.4 -0.423 -16.4 -17.7563 -1.3563 (8.3%)
2011-01-01
(2011Q1)
9.4 -0.204 -10.5 -12.6876 -2.1876 (20.8%)
2010-10-01
(2010Q4)
9.9 -0.438 -10.5 -20.7362 -10.2362 (97.5%)
2010-07-01
(2010Q3)
9.8 -0.195 -8.8 -14.5855 -5.7855 (65.7%)
2010-04-01
(2010Q2)
10.0 0.052 -7.1 -9.9218 -2.8218 (39.7%)
2010-01-01
(2010Q1)
9.5 0.553 -5.5 4.3065 9.8065 (-178.3%)
2009-10-01
(2009Q4)
9.0 1.581 14.0 30.7321 16.7321 (119.5%)
2009-07-01
(2009Q3)
7.8 2.34 31.5 54.6176 23.1176 (73.4%)
2009-04-01
(2009Q2)
6.5 2.506 39.6 65.3048 25.7048 (64.9%)
2009-01-01
(2009Q1)
5.8 0.762 64.2 28.6262 -35.5738 (-55.4%)
2008-10-01
(2008Q4)
5.0 0.8 83.6 33.7182 -49.8818 (-59.7%)
2008-07-01
(2008Q3)
5.0 0.464 57.7 25.9415 -31.7585 (-55.0%)
2008-04-01
(2008Q2)
4.7 0.022 55.4 17.2912 -38.1088 (-68.8%)
2008-01-01
(2008Q1)
4.7 -0.366 32.1 8.311 -23.789 (-74.1%)
2007-10-01
(2007Q4)
4.5 -0.557 19.2 4.9435 -14.2565 (-74.3%)
2007-07-01
(2007Q3)
4.6 -0.622 7.5 2.9125 -4.5875 (-61.2%)
2007-04-01
(2007Q2)
4.4 -0.577 -3.8 5.0071 8.8071 (-231.8%)
2007-01-01
(2007Q1)
4.7 -0.5 0.0 5.2096 5.2096
2006-10-01
(2006Q4)
4.7 -0.582 0.0 3.3118 3.3118
2006-07-01
(2006Q3)
4.7 -0.55 -8.9 4.0524 12.9524 (-145.5%)
2006-04-01
(2006Q2)
5.0 -0.541 -12.3 2.681 14.981 (-121.8%)
2006-01-01
(2006Q1)
5.0 -0.577 -10.7 1.8478 12.5478 (-117.3%)
2005-10-01
(2005Q4)
5.2 -0.596 -8.8 0.355 9.155 (-104.0%)
2005-07-01
(2005Q3)
5.3 -0.667 -16.7 -1.8149 14.8851 (-89.1%)
2005-04-01
(2005Q2)
5.5 -0.671 -24.1 -2.9606 21.1394 (-87.7%)
2005-01-01
(2005Q1)
5.5 -0.664 -23.6 -2.7985 20.8015 (-88.1%)
2004-10-01
(2004Q4)
5.6 -0.742 -21.1 -5.1304 15.9696 (-75.7%)
2004-07-01
(2004Q3)
5.7 -0.731 -20.0 -5.4024 14.5976 (-73.0%)
2004-04-01
(2004Q2)
6.0 -0.674 -22.8 -5.6628 17.1372 (-75.2%)
2004-01-01
(2004Q1)
6.2 -0.688 -17.9 -7.0399 10.8601 (-60.7%)